Ethical Dilemmas in Health Policymaking

Salehi , Tahmine

Volume 17 - Supplement of 11th Annual Iranian Congress of Medical Ethics (Oral Presentation) IJMEHM 2024, 17 - Supplement of 11th Annual Iranian Congress of Medical Ethics (Oral Presentation): 1-3 | Back to browse issues page

Mendeley

Zotero

RefWorks

Salehi T. Ethical Dilemmas in Health Policymaking. IJMEHM 2024; 17 (S1) :1-3
URL: http://ijme.tums.ac.ir/article-1-6866-en.html

Ethical Dilemmas in Health Policymaking

Tahmine Salehi ^*

Associate Professor Nursing Management Department, School of Nursing and Midwifery, Iran University of Medical Sciences, Tehran, Iran

Abstract: (35 Views)

Ethical considerations have been underemphasized in health system policymaking compared to areas like clinical ethics and biomedical research. Allocating resources effectively, promoting equitable access, and resolving societal needs within the health system necessitate robust ethical frameworks. Neglecting these frameworks creates significant dilemmas and challenges. An analysis of health system policymaking and macro-decision-making reveals a pervasive disregard for systemic ethical thinking. A primary ethical dilemma stems from conflicts of interest, leading to policy choices that may not prioritize ethical service delivery. This can manifest as over-provision, non-standard services, or diminished quality of care. Economic constraints pose another critical dilemma, characterized by inadequate health expenditure as a proportion of gross domestic product (GDP). This limits equitable access to healthcare and exacerbates inequities in resource distribution. A prime example is the neglect of the network-based health system, favoring hosp ital-centric development and an overemphasis on specialized care over comprehensive primary care. Determining the appropriate model for the health system – enterprise-driven or governance-oriented – presents a fundamental conflict. This choice significantly influences health policy decisions. Furthermore, the simultaneous role of policymakers as both providers and purchasers of healthcare services fuels conflicts of interest and incentivizes "induced demand."Shifting towards an ethical perspective in health system policymaking requires a systemic and comprehensive approach. Incorporating ethical considerations into policy decisions, recognizing the unique characteristics of the health market, and addressing conflicts of interest are crucial for improving system performance. This approach would likely prioritize network-based care, strengthen primary care, enhance referral systems, develop a robust primary care workforce, and elevate the importance of health education within the system.

Keywords: Policymaking, Health policymaking, Ethical dilemma, Ethical challenges

Full-Text [PDF 379 kb] (16 Downloads)

Type of Study: Ethics Congress | Subject: Congress of Ethics
Received: 2025/02/4 | Accepted: 2024/12/22 | Published: 2024/12/22